Causes of the Crash - and speculation's role
In the later 1920s share prices rose far above companies' real value as buyers piled in, many 'on the margin' (often a 10% deposit, the rest borrowed), so a small fall could ruin them. Confidence broke in late October 1929 - 'Black Thursday' (24 Oct) and the far worse 'Black Tuesday' (29 Oct). Deeper causes mattered too: industrial and farm overproduction, and unequal wealth. 'How far to blame?' treats speculation as the trigger, weighed against these structural weaknesses.
Consequences and Hoover's response
The Crash hit banking confidence: banks that had backed speculators failed, wiping out savings; unemployment reached about a quarter of the workforce. Evicted families built shanty 'Hoovervilles'; men rode freight trains for work; soup kitchens spread. Hoover believed in 'rugged individualism' - self-reliance over federal relief. He acted only modestly (the Reconstruction Finance Corporation, 1932); removing the Bonus Army veterans in 1932 left him deeply unpopular.
Drawn from real examiner reports.
Causes question, consequences answer
On the causes of the Depression, candidates write about its consequences instead - unemployment, bank failures, Hoovervilles - describing what happened afterwards rather than what caused the Crash. A causes answer needs speculation, margin buying and overproduction. Before including a point, check it explains why the Crash came, not what followed.
On causes of the Depression, candidates write about its consequences instead (Paper 4).
Under-using agricultural causes
Agricultural causes of the Depression are under-used. American farmers faced foreign competition (Europe recovering after the war) and tariffs that invited retaliation against US exports, on top of chronic overproduction that kept prices low even during the boom. This left much of the economy fragile before October 1929 - use it in a causes answer, not just the stock market.
Agricultural causes - tariffs, foreign competition, overproduction - are under-used (Paper 4).
The Dust Bowl is a 1930s event
On 1920s farmers' problems, some wrongly bring in the Dust Bowl or describe the general boom. The Dust Bowl (drought and soil erosion on the Great Plains) is a separate 1930s disaster. The 1920s problems were chronic overproduction, falling prices, foreign competition and tariffs. Keep the two apart - one helped cause the Depression, the other deepened it.
On 1920s farmers' problems, some bring in 1930s material such as the Dust Bowl (Paper 1, Paper 4).
Hoover's aid isn't the New Deal
Don't confuse Hoover's response with Roosevelt's New Deal. Hoover favoured limited, voluntary action ('rugged individualism') plus modest measures like the Reconstruction Finance Corporation (1932). Roosevelt promised an active federal 'New Deal' - but its detailed programmes came after he took office in 1933, not during the 1932 campaign.
'Hoover did nothing' overstates it
Answers often claim Hoover did nothing. In fact he took some action - notably the Reconstruction Finance Corporation (1932), lending to banks and businesses - but it was too limited, too indirect and too late for suffering families, and he resisted direct federal relief. Argue that his response was inadequate to the crisis, not literally non-existent.
The Crash and the Depression are one event
A testable error. The Wall Street Crash was the share-price collapse in late October 1929. The Great Depression was the longer collapse - bank failures, closures, mass unemployment, hardship - that followed over years. Treating them as one, or placing Hoovervilles in October 1929, misses the causal chain: the Crash triggered the knock-on collapse that became the Depression.
Students conflate the Wall Street Crash with the Great Depression that followed (general exam technique).
Weigh speculation vs structural causes
For 'how far was speculation responsible?', explain speculation and margin buying, then a structural counter-factor (overproduction, unequal wealth), before a judgement - speculation was the trigger, but structural weakness made the crash a long depression.
Stop before the aftermath
For any 'causes' question, apply a discipline: if a sentence describes bank failures, unemployment, Hoovervilles or the 1932 election, it belongs in a consequences answer, not a causes one. Check what the question asks and cut aftermath detail from a causes response.
Stay in the date range
Keep to the period the question names. Material outside it dilutes relevance - a common fault here is dragging the 1930s Dust Bowl into a 1920s farming answer, or the New Deal into a 1932-election answer. Check the dates and cut anything that falls outside them.
Match the command word
Part (a) 'describe' wants short factual points; part (b) 'explain why' wants developed reasons, not narrative; 'how far' wants two sides and a weighed judgement. Identify the command word before writing so that you answer what is actually asked.
In October 1929 share prices on the New York Stock Exchange collapsed within days, wiping out billions of dollars of paper wealth. The Crash was not a single, simple cause -- reckless speculation and "margin buying" combined with deeper structural weaknesses, especially industrial overproduction and a farming sector that had never shared fully in the 1920s boom. The Crash triggered the Great Depression: bank failures, business collapse, and mass unemployment with severe social consequences. President Hoover's limited response left him unpopular, and Franklin D. R
Full notes, flashcards, Q&A and the topic quiz for every premium subject.
Premium plans are US$8.99/month or US$49.99/year — first month free.
Studying with a parent's blessing? Show them this.