The Roaring Twenties: new mass media
New mass media spread widely. Hollywood's silent films drew huge audiences, with the first 'talkies' by the decade's end; jazz, rooted in Black American traditions, gave the era its name, the Jazz Age; and radio spread fast, carrying music and news into homes. Urban 'flappers' captured the mood. But it was overwhelmingly urban - rural, more religious America often did not share it and resented it, a tension seen in Prohibition, the Scopes Trial and the Klan.
Change vs intolerance: the both-sides frame
Hold two views together. Change: mass media (film, jazz, radio) built a new culture, the Nineteenth Amendment (1920) gave women the vote, and urban 'flappers' won new freedoms. Backlash: the Red Scare and Palmer Raids (1919-20); the Immigration Acts (1921, 1924) favouring north-west Europeans; the Scopes Trial (1925); the revived Klan targeting Black Americans, Catholics, Jews and immigrants; and discrimination against Black Americans despite the Harlem Renaissance.
Drawn from real examiner reports.
Scopes: explain why, don't narrate
Candidates retell the Scopes Trial (1925) - teacher John Scopes prosecuted in Tennessee for teaching evolution - but asked why it was controversial, they re-narrate rather than explain. It exposed a culture war: rural Fundamentalists (the 'Bible Belt') took the Bible's creation account literally and opposed teaching evolution, while urban modernists backed it as science.
Candidates describe the Monkey Trial rather than explain why it was controversial (Paper 1).
Prohibition's wartime/nationalist causes
On why Prohibition came in, candidates describe alcohol's social harms (temperance groups like the Anti-Saloon League) but under-explain the First World War angle: much US brewing had German-American roots, so wartime anti-German feeling made it a target, and grain was seen as needed for the war effort. Combine the moral, wartime and religious causes.
Causes of Prohibition: the WWI/nationalistic angle is under-explained (Paper 1).
Protestant, not Catholic, churches
A flagged misconception: some think the Roman Catholic Church campaigned for Prohibition. In fact chiefly Protestant churches and rural, Fundamentalist-leaning communities pushed for it; Catholic and immigrant communities, often urban, were generally more resistant, as moderate drinking had an accepted social role. Get the religious alignment the right way round.
Misconception that the Roman Catholic, not Protestant, churches campaigned for Prohibition (Paper 4).
Prohibition: causes vs effects
Asked for the causes of Prohibition, some candidates instead describe its effects - bootlegging, speakeasies and gangster violence (e.g. Al Capone in Chicago). Those are creditworthy only for an effects or repeal question. Keep causes (temperance, wartime anti-German feeling, religious backing) separate from consequences, and check the command word first.
Some confuse the causes of Prohibition with its effects, e.g. bootlegging violence (Paper 4).
Red Scare isn't the Klan's revival
Do not blur the Red Scare with the 1920s Klan. The Red Scare (1919-20) targeted suspected communists and radicals via the Palmer Raids and deportations, amid fear after the 1917 Russian Revolution. The revived Klan targeted Black Americans, Catholics, Jews and immigrants through intimidation and violence. Related moods, different targets and methods.
The vote wasn't full equality
The Nineteenth Amendment (1920) gave women the national vote, but did not end unequal pay, limited jobs or traditional expectations. Change was real but partial: 'flappers' and new office and shop work were largely urban and middle-class, while most women kept traditional domestic roles. Don't equate the vote with full equality.
Myth: the Catholic Church backed Prohibition
A confusion examiners flag. Prohibition's strongest support came from Protestant temperance groups (like the Anti-Saloon League) and rural Fundamentalist communities. The Roman Catholic Church and many Catholic immigrant communities, mostly urban, were more resistant. Students who think 'the Catholic Church campaigned for Prohibition' have the alignment backwards.
Misconception that the Roman Catholic Church, not the Protestant churches, campaigned for Prohibition (Paper 4).
Weigh both sides for 'how far'
For 'how far did society change?', develop both change (media, women's vote, flappers) and backlash (Red Scare, immigration quotas, the Klan, racism), each with named detail, then judge which mattered more. Don't argue one side or restate points.
Check causes vs effects
Part (a) 'describe' wants short factual points, no explanation. Part (b) 'explain why' wants reasons, not narrative. Check whether the question asks for causes or effects before writing - a common slip on Prohibition.
Sources: interpret, don't summarise
On Paper 2 sources, interpret rather than describe. For a cartoon 'message', combine all details for the big message; don't take a caption literally or misidentify who is shown. A biased source is still useful as evidence of a viewpoint.
Ground the final source answer
For 'how far do the sources support X', test the hypothesis exactly as worded, then work through supporting and opposing sources using quotations. Don't write a general-knowledge essay or claim support without linking a quotation to the hypothesis.
The 1920s in the United States is often called the "Roaring Twenties" -- a decade of new mass media, consumer culture and, for some, new social freedoms. But it was also a decade of deep intolerance: restricted immigration, a Red Scare, religious conservatism, and violent racial discrimination. This Key Question asks you to weigh genuine social change against the limits and backlash it provoked.
Full notes, flashcards, Q&A and the topic quiz for every premium subject.
Premium plans are US$8.99/month or US$49.99/year — first month free.
Studying with a parent's blessing? Show them this.
